Poland POLAND 2024 - Luna - The Tower

[ESC United Mod Team]

 

[ayzelto]

What a flawless choice! I'm delighted and happy to see Poland represented by a modern pop song this year (and that I don't have to wait until 4pm to find out).
Jutyna would be an amazing entrant but the chorus of her submitted song was very Eurovision-esque. I think that Luna's entry feels slightly more natural(?).

I'm a half-time Swiftie and I like such dreamy pop music. Thus, from me.

Oh wait. I didn’t read that.

And after listening to it: it sounds like a JESC entry to me. I’d rather say the song is kinda average.

Edit 3 after 3rd listen: I think I like this. I don’t want to, but I actually do.

 

[MopManMoss]

It's competent and respectable but I feel like it doesn't go anywhere personally

 

[empo21]

I like this more than Justyna's messy song

The Tower has a nice chorus, but overall the song doesn't pack a punch so it's quite flat. Nice staging and good vocals will likely help it pass the semis easily.

First impression but maybe if it grows on me. Fits nicely with the pool of middle of the road songs that is the majority of the lineup so far.

 

[ayzelto]

On the first listen, it was kind of "meh," but after three times, I actually liked it. It sounds a bit Junior Eurovision-ish, but I can't help but like it. 8 points from me!

 

[Looren]

Catchy chorus but meh verses, okay-ish song overall

or , will need a second lesson

 

[simonPL]

Good luck, Luna.

Please, survive the first wave of Justyna’s fans comments. xddd

 

[GRE]

Well done Poland,

We need fresh modern pop music,

You don't need trash pop to stand out.

 

[marty]

Its not bad but somehow it is too generic. I dont have the wish to listen to it a second time. I give 3 points.

 

[ZoboCamel]

Aww; I haven't been following Poland too closely, but from what I have heard, I would've much preferred Justyna, who would've been a solid 8 or something for me. Not my winner for sure, but in my top half for the year.

This, by contrast, is just... there. Very much "in one ear, out the other." They're out-Denmarking Denmark in the "generic radio song" category; at least Denmark's sending a decent, enjoyable example of that "genre" this year.

This just feels... bland. Forgettable. Devoid of emotion. It's not offensively bad, but I can't find a single element that catches my interest or ventures even an inch beyond the modern radio pop formula I've heard thousands of times before.

. Hopefully it grows on me, but I'm not too optimistic.


EDIT: Damn.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1759489674190483678

 

[HarryUK]

It’s a good entry but Justyna has more flavour & a more unique song imo

 

[empo21]

Justyna losing by 1 point. If I were TVP, I'd take that secret to the grave

TVP loves torturing their people fr

 

[JChan]

I feel like I need to take some time to rate this since I'm little biased by Justyna.

That being said, it reminds me of Iceland's entry last year in terms of vibes and I'm not necessarily sure that's a good thing.

TVP revealing that Justyna lost by one point does make think that maybe those people that tried to storm its headquaters were on to someting /s

 

[lasse braun]

i do not know all internal songs but i think this is the best choice aside from the stunning ethnobanger.
or (must hear the 2-3 times more...)
poland was with his decision not to choose the top10 (maybe top5) ethnobanger also very friendly to the ukraine and also estonia - so estonia has now the bopethnobanger this year and not poland.
i like "the tower" much more than p.e. "tattoo".

 

[Jupiter]

Gets a from me. Her voice isn't for me and I forgot about the song while it was still running. Given that this performs in the first half of semi 1, it looks like a NQ to me.

Justynas song was messy, but at least that kept my attention. And we could have had more witches at ESC. That joke alone was better to me then this entry 'xD

 

[ZoboCamel]

poland was with his decision not to choose the top10 (maybe top5) ethnobanger also very friendly to the ukraine and also estonia - so estonia has now the bopethnobanger this year and not poland.

I suppose I can take that as a silver lining... I would've definitely preferred Justyna over Luna, but at the same time I prefer our other witchy entries (especially Ireland and Norway) over Justyna, so if Poland sending this lets those others stand out more and score better, I guess it's not all bad

 

[Realest]

Well done Neighbours.
As usual, you can count on our Support.

 

[randajad]

Polish entry not being dated garbage is a nice change, but the song still could have gone somewhere more interesting. 5/10

 

[AlekS]

My source was right. I have known it was her for 2 days (it was hard to keep silence, I shared only with 1 person here) I've got impression that TVP didn't tell her right away tho.
Judging from our community's reaction, Poland won't receive 12 pts from Ukraine this year.
To me personally, Justyna's song was Loboda-like messy (7-8 pts). Luna's song is ok, not outsdanding and not bad. I give it a

 

[Yoozek]

Of course Kasia Moś as part of the jury loved the song's rhyming tower/power
Of course they chose something "modern" with vid about someone old, someone androgenous, someone afroamerican cause it's so 2020ish and leftist. They pulled on a netflix approach to the witcher theme. Replaced it with fancy looking trash and called it a day.

Bye

 

[Genesis]

I am so so so so disappointed.

Lunas song is not bad but just bit bland. I would give it 5 or 6.

I can't believe we will never get to see the actual ESC performance of witcher and what Justyna could have done with it. Shame.