Best/Worst Jury-Decisions 2009-2017

[Realest]

Lets see which Jury-Decisions you liked/dislikes in the last Few Years:

Good Decisions:

2010: Putting on 3rd Place and on 4th Place / Pulling and down / Trying to help and eliminate
2011: Saving from Elimination /
2012: Saving / High voting for and /
2013: High voting for / trying to save
2014: Helping to overtake / Saving from Elimination /
2015: Helping to win (even if Italy was my #2) / helping to a fair result/
2016: Helping Jamala to win / Eliminating in order to save / Voting for and / Trying to help qualifying /
2017: Saving and eliminating /

Bad Decisions:

2009: Overrating , , , and underrating , , , and
2010: Eliminating and trying to eliminate / Saving and /
2011: Massive Overrating of , and / Damaging original Entries like / Eliminating
2012: Overrating , and / Underrating of and / the Unforgiveable Elimination of
2013: (at least) Spanish, Italian and french Juries killing / Probably eliminating , and me/ Overrating , and
2014: Several Juries killing and / Overrating and / Saving from its deserved elimination/ Trying to eliminate /
2015: Overrating , and / Underrating , and / Trying to eliminate / Saving and killing
2016: Overrating , and / Underrating , and / Killing in order to save
2017: Overrating (again), , and hurting original Entries like and / Trying to eliminate , and but celebrating , and .

 

[midnightsun]

worst:

2011: Blue and Alex V
2012: Iceland

 

[carl1]

Finland 2017 was horrendously underrated

 

[VikingTiger]

Best jury result (shouldnt come as a surprise): 2009; Ranking Patricia Kaas 4th. While the mob gave her 17th place...

The worst ever jury desicion is just as easy, and had catastrophic consequences: Dethroning Italy and Il Volo - handing over the trophy to Heroes...

 

[Brandt]

Bad Decisions

2017 "Line"
Just 1 point? Really?

2017 "Spirit of the night"
Not even 1 point, really?

2016 "Play"
Pretty much the same reason

2010
Jury is the reason it didn't make it to the final.

2017
Giving too much credits for this song...

 

[Kaz]

Good decisions

2010 - attempting to help qualify over , and saving from NQing
2011 - ranking first in its semi and Top 5 in the final
2012 - pushing and into the Top 10
2013 - attempting to help , , and qualify
2014 - stopped from placing 11th with the televote alone
2015 - would have prevented and from finishing with 0 points, if the new voting system were implemented
2016 - not letting win
2017 - helping , , and

Bad decisions

2010 - ranking higher in the final than , , and
2011 - ranking first in its semi, attempting to make , , and qualify
2012 - attempting to make qualify over
2013 - pushing into the final
2014 - ranking and dead last in their semis
2015 - ranking 9th in their semi, 10th in their semi and second-last in the final, and making qualify over
2016 - overrating so extravagantly in both the semi and final
2017 - giving only one point to in the semi, letting qualify and finish in Top 10, letting finish Top 5, pushing for , , , and to qualify over , , , and

 

[popavapeur]

Best : Poland 2016 - Where it should have landed
Worst : Malta 2016 - thanks god viewers shredded this song to pieces

 

[midnightsun]

Worst: Croatia 2017

 

[Citelis]

Best: 2016 was a masterpiece that should have won

Worst: 2017 didn't diserved top 10

 

[carl1]

Of course, the worst one is the juries robbing Il Volo of their deserved victory, still mad about that

 

[ag89]

2009

BEST: putting France and UK high, putting Azerbaijan low

2010

BEST: putting Belgium and Georgia high

2011:

BEST: putting Slovenia and Austria high, putting Sweden low

2012

BEST: putting Albania high, so deserved

2013

BEST: cannot remember, this year was strange
WORST: putting Montenegro so low

2014: it was all ok

2015

BEST: putting Latvia high!
WORST: obviously Italy

2016

BEST: Australia landsliding, Poland being second last, I don't get the song, putting Belgium high
WORST: they were mean to Russia, even too Ukraine too (around 20 juries gave zero to both)

2017

BEST: recognizing Portugal
WORST: putting Australia so high, and Belgium low

 

[BernadetteCydonia]

Best: actually making Malta qualify in 2012. As I was probably the biggest possible fan of it imaginable in .net at the time, I was possibly imagining myself to move on from its loss immediately, but then Malta ended up announced and I was like "YASSSSS ". That was shocking but I loved it! I love when my big faves qualify in general!
Worst: overrating Ukraine 2012, not making Belarus 2016 and Montenegro 2013 qualify... and idk else

 

[SiXo]

Worst: Making Heros winner instead of a masterpiece Grande Amore.

 

[FreeFair]

Best of Juries 2011: Austria out of bottom 5 (though they went too far putting Italy 2nd IMO)
Worst of Juries 2011: Overrating Slovenia
Best of Juries 2012: Upgrading Italy
Worst of 2012: Nothing that I can see.
Best of Juries 2013: Moldova in the Final
Worst of Juries 2013: Montenegro Out
Best of Juries 2014: Same top 4 as Public
Worst of Juries 2014: Portugal Out, Azerbaijan Qualify
Best of Juries 2015: Boosting Norway
Worst of Juries 2015 : Underrating Spain
Best of Juries 2016: Upgrading Malta
Worst Of Juries 2016: Overrating Australia & Israel
Best of Juries 2017: Giving Norway a well deserved top 10.
Worst Of Juries 2017: Overrating Australia

 

[Neo]

The political jury vote against Russia in 2016 was a disgrace, and agree with others about 2015 Italy - Il Volo for Sweden - Heroes

 

[Realest]

The political jury vote against Russia in 2016 was a disgrace, and agree with others about 2015 Italy - Il Volo for Sweden - Heroes

It is not political to give 0 Points to Sergey. Juries can only give Points to 10/25 Countries and 0 to 15 others.
Also Juries couldnt foresee that Il Volo would win the TV with that Huge Margin.

 

[lolita]

2017- putting , in front of -pure nonsense!

 

[Realest]

2018:

Eliminating Greece and saving Albania.
Eliminating Poland and saving Netherlands.
Giving Austria 1st Place.
Giving Sweden 2nd Place.
Giving Ukraine Last Place.
Keeping Denmark outside Top5.

 

[midnightsun]

2018:
Keeping Denmark outside Top5.

Worst decision ever!

 

[Preuss]

ISAIAH FOURTH PLACE AND NINTH PLACE OVERALL