AUSTRIA 2011 - Nadine Beiler - The Secret is Love

[adamsamways]

Austria qualifying is one of the only good things about tonight for me, I wish you all the luck in the final!

 

[94ayd]

Maybe the strongest vocal performance but the song was bottom 5 worthy.

 

[Simon87]

Congrats Nadine

 

[r3gg13]

Agree! She will qualify, you'll see

We did see that she qualified I wasn't too surprised since her voice/song is breath taking.

Quentin must be happy too

 

[deese]

Maybe the strongest vocal performance but the song was bottom 5 worthy.

totally agree

 

[PeterLPZ]

Congrats to Austria and to Nadine. This was so awesome yesterday. I called for this song and I was so happy, that Nadine is in the final.
Gut gemacht und viel Glück am Samstag!!!

 

[Kryptonite]

Great song, great performer. It really deserved to qualify!

 

[Narmina]

Congratulations Austria!

 

[Grinch]

Congrats Austria. Blue members love her voice

 

[escandesc]

I hadn't listened to the song until yesterday actually I listened but just 2 or 3 times. but I really loved her voice yesterday and wasn't surprised to learn that Austria was in the final. congratulations Austria!

 

[A-lister]

I knew the juries would love this pile of crap.

3 minutes of vocal gymnastics, no actual melody, dated and no real charisma. Would work in Idol, but again (as with the Lithuanian mess of a song) this is supposed to be a song contest and not Idol for American disney stuff.

This took the place of some more deserving qualifier.

So now they juries got all their Disney ballads in the final...

 

[Molecular]

I knew the juries would love this pile of crap.

3 minutes of vocal gymnastics, no actual melody, dated and no real charisma. Would work in Idol, but again (as with the Lithuanian mess of a song) this is supposed to be a song contest and not Idol for American disney stuff.

This took the place of some more deserving qualifier.

So now they juries got all their Disney ballads in the final...

Yes, instead of only real gymnastics, as the swedish guy did! 3

You should just be happy that all the teen girls voted for him and not post your "pile of crap" in here...

But the more important: Congrats to Nadine!

 

[Sahistul]

@A-Lister, sincerely now, Popular by Saade it's a piece of musical art? And I refere to all components of a song. I think only by show is...

But this is Nadine we speak here, sorry. Success in the final!!

 

[A-lister]

@A-Lister, sincerely now, Popular by Saade it's a piece of musical art?

But this is Nadine we speak here, sorry. Success in the final!!

Exactly, we talk about the Austrian entry here so I don't get your question?

To answer the weird question though (as if that would make the Austrian song any better lol?)

No, Eric's song is so not a masterpiece by any means, it's just a catchy simple pop tune.. Atleast to me it's a song unlike 3 minutes of wailing.

But taste differs yep.

 

[A-lister]

Yes, instead of only real gymnastics, as the swedish guy did! 3

I didn't know this was the Swedish thread? I must have missed something?

Yeah he performed a show, what did you think he was suppose to do with an uptempo song? Just stand there?

And since he alteast had a song which may be not that very good, but atleast something I could enjoy at a party or something and sing-along to.. i'd rather take that over 3 minutes of wail.

Anyways I'm happy you as a country is back in the game, but I'd prefer something else as a song though.

 

[Sahistul]

You made some considerations about the austrian song and thats why i asked about the swedish, i was curious how you judge it.

 

[A-lister]

You made some considerations about the austrian song and thats why i asked about the swedish, i was curious how you judge it.

Yes because this is the Austrian thread, it's a place to discuss the Austrian entry. I love how some people assume that turning critizicm towards another entry will make something else look better?

Anyways you got your answer nevertheless.

 

[Sahistul]

And I thank you, sorry for the off-topic, we could discuse about Saade on his thread!

 

[A-lister]

And I thank you, sorry for the off-topic, we could discuse about Saade on his thread!

No problem Yes we could (and should)

 

[Molecular]

Yes because this is the Austrian thread, it's a place to discuss the Austrian entry. I love how some people assume that turning critizicm towards another entry will make something else look better?

Anyways you got your answer nevertheless.

Well, I think that calling something a "pile of crap" is disrespectful, and that's what you are.