Contact us

2014 VS 2015

QwaarJet
scotland

QwaarJet

ESC Moderator
Joined
March 27, 2010
Posts
9,210
Location
Kilmacolm,Scotland
OK, so this is to stop the spam in the other thread.

Compare each country's songs from last year and this year and at the end calculate which year is better. I'll do mine later.
 
12Points

12Points

Active member
Joined
July 21, 2013
Posts
1,206
My picks :D

:am: 2015
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2014
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015
:de: 2015
:gr: 2015		:hu: 2014
:is: 2015
:ie: 2015
:il: 2014
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2015
:md: 2014
:nl: 2015
:pl: 2014
:pt: 2015
:ro: 2015
:sl: 2015
:es: 2014
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2014

2015:2014
19:9
Clearly this year's my favorite :D
 
Matt
united_states

Matt

Admin Schmadmin
Staff member
Joined
June 1, 2009
Posts
23,485
Location
Los Angeles, USA
:am: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2014
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2014
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2014
:de: 2015
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2014
:ie: 2015
:il: 2015
:it: 2015
:lv: 2014
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2014
:md: 2015
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2015
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2015

2014: 15
2015: 13

2015 is catching up but last year is still strong IMO.
 
poland

revallsay

Well-known member
Joined
January 7, 2014
Posts
8,132
:am: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2014
:dk: 2015
:fi: 2014*
:fr: 2014*
:ge: 2014
:de: 2014
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2014
:ie: 2014
:il: 2014*
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2015*
:md: 2015
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2015
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2014

2014: 16
2015: 12

* I also love the other year.
 
ayzelto
spain

ayzelto

Well-known member
Joined
February 10, 2010
Posts
2,655
Location
Barcelona
:am: 2015
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2015
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2015
:de: 2014
:gr: 2015
:hu: 2014
:is: 2015
:ie: 2014
:il: 2014
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2014
:md: 2015
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
United%20Kingdom(Great%20Britain).png
2014

2014: 12
2015: 16
 
france

Rayman

Member
Joined
June 3, 2014
Posts
212
Location
Limoges
:am: 2014
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2015
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015
:de: 2015
:gr: 2015
:hu: 2014
:is: 2015
:ie: 2015
:il: 2014
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2014
:md: 2014
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2015
::sl: 2014
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
:uk: 2015

2014: 9
2015: 19

So yes, Vienna is winning in my mind.
 
Mattan
finland

Mattan

Active member
Joined
March 17, 2013
Posts
620
:am: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2014
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2014
:de: 2015
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2014
:ie: 2015
:il: 2014
:it: 2014
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2014
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2014
:md: 2014
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2014
:pt: 2015
:ro: 2015
:sl: 2015
:es: 2014
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2014

2014: 19
2015: 9

I'm kind of surprised the margin isn't bigger, because the overall level of 2014 was better by an even bigger margin by that (then again, this doesn't take into account the magnitude of the difference in my opinion between entries). Still, with 2014 currently having over double the entries of 2015, I can surely say I prefer that. Out of the next songs selected, I don't know about Austria, but Sweden will nearly certainly be better than their bad 2014 and Norway worse than their very good effort.
 
Leydan

Leydan

Worldvision Mod
Staff member
Joined
March 1, 2013
Posts
18,285
Location
UK
:am: 2014
:at: 2014
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2014
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015
:de: 2014
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2015
:ie: 2014
:il: 2014
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2015
:mt: 2015
:md: 2014
:nl: 2015
:pl: 2014
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
:uk: 2015

2014: 13
2015: 16
 
RainyWoods
uk

RainyWoods

Croak-kay
Joined
February 9, 2012
Posts
25,225
Location
London
:am: 2015
:at: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2015 (I dislike both)
:fi: 2015
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2014
:de: 2014
:gr: 2015
:hu: 2014 (I dislike both)
:is: 2014
:ie: 2015
:il: 2015
:it: 2014
:lv: 2015 (I love both)
:lt: 2014
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2015
:md: 2014
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
:uk: 2015

2014: 14
2015: 15


Why is 2015 winning by 1 point for me? I'm supposed to be hating this yearxgaah
 
Sean
canada

Sean

Admin
Staff member
Joined
September 28, 2009
Posts
17,058
Location
British Columbia, Canada
:am: 2014
:at: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2015
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2014 (I like both pretty equally)
:de: 2015
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2014
:ie: 2015
:il: 2015
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2014
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2014
:md: 2015 (but I don't really like either)
:nl: 2015
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2015

2014: 15
2015: 14

Seems about right
 
Simon87

Simon87

Well-known member
Joined
November 15, 2009
Posts
11,410
Location
Simon city
:am: 2014 (not a fan of this one either)
:at: 2014
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015
:dk: 2014 (dont like this one too)
:fi: 2014 (dont like this one too)
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015 (not a fan)
:de: 2015
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2015 (not a fan)
:ie: 2014
:il: 2015
:it: 2014
:lv: 2015 (not a big fan)
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2015
:md: 2014
:nl: 2015
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
United%20Kingdom(Great%20Britain).png
2014

2014: 13
2015: 16
 
Staewi
germany

Staewi

Well-known member
Joined
March 24, 2012
Posts
4,092
:am: 2015
:at: 2014
:by: 2014
:be: 2015
:ee: 2015*
:dk: 2014 (both horrible)
:fi: 2014 (easy choice, but I dislike Something Better)
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2015
:de: 2015*
:gr: 2014*
:hu: 2014*
:is: 2015
:ie: 2015
:il: 2014*
:it: 2014*
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2014
:mk: 2014*
:mt: 2015
:md: 2015
:nl: 2014
:pl: 2014
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015*
:es: 2015
:ch: 2015
:uk: 2015

2014: 15
2015: 13
* I really like both
 
GRE
greece

GRE

Well-known member
Joined
December 6, 2010
Posts
8,011
Location
Greece
:am: None
:at: Both
:by: 2014
:be: Both
:ee: 2015
:dk: None
:fi: None
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015
:de: Both
:gr: None
:hu: 2015
:is: 2014
:ie: 2014
:il: Both
:it: 2015
:lv: 2014
:lt: 2015
:mk: None
:mt: 2015
:md: 2014
:nl: 2014
:pl: None
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2015
:sl: Both
:es: 2015
:ch: None
:uk: Both

2014=>7
2015=>9
 
QwaarJet
scotland

QwaarJet

ESC Moderator
Joined
March 27, 2010
Posts
9,210
Location
Kilmacolm,Scotland
So far :

:am: 2014
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:ee: 2014
:dk: 2015
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2015
:ge: 2015
:de: 2014
:gr: 2015
:hu: 2015
:is: 2015
:ie: 2014
:il: 2014
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2014
:md: 2014
:nl: 2015
:pl: 2015
:pt: 2015
:ro: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2015
:ch: 2014
United%20Kingdom%28Great%20Britain%29.png
2014

2014 : 12
2015 : 16

Some duds have been selected lately, but 2015 is still obviously the superior year. My only issue is that I haven't found THAT song that I want to win.
 
ZoboCamel
australia

ZoboCamel

Well-known member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Posts
4,521
Location
Melbourne, Australia
:am: - 2014
:at: - 2014
:by: - 2015
:be: - Tie
:dk: - 2014
:ee: - 2015
:fi: - 2014
:fr: - 2015
:mk: - 2015
:ge: - 2015
:de: - 2015
:gr: - 2014
:hu: - 2014
:il: - 2015
:ie: - Tie
:is: - 2015
:it: - 2015
:lv: - 2015
:lt: - 2015
:mt: - 2015
:md: - 2015
:nl: - 2014
:no: - 2014
:pl: - 2014
:pt: - 2014
:ro: - 2014
:sl: - Tie
:es: - 2015
:se: - 2014
:ch: - 2014
:uk: - 2014

2014: 14
2015: 14
Ties: 3

I thought that this year felt about the same in strength as last year, and it seems like my comparisons agree! It'll be interesting to see how the last songs tip the scales.
 
Dante
romania

Dante

Active member
Joined
June 19, 2014
Posts
1,141
Location
Bucharest, Romania
:am: - 2014
:at: - 2014
:by: - 2014
:be: - 2014
:dk: - 2014
:ee: - 2015
:fi: - 2015
:fr: - 2015
:mk: - 2014
:ge: - 2014
:de: - 2015
:gr: - 2014
:hu: - 2014
:il: - 2015
:ie: - 2015
:is: - 2015
:it: - 2014
:lv: - 2015
:lt: - 2015
:mt: - 2014
:md: - 2015
:nl: - 2014
:no: - 2015
:pl: - 2014
:pt: - 2015
:ro: - 2014
:sl: - 2014
:es: - 2015
:se: - 2015
:ch: - 2014
:uk: - 2015

2014: 16
2015: 15



For some was so hard to choose, since I consider both being weak years. Between 2 bad songs, I usually go with the up-tempo one.
 
estonia

blein

Active member
Joined
March 1, 2012
Posts
1,649
:ee: 2015
:se: 2014
:ge: 2015
:sl: 2015
:fi: 2014
:uk: 2014
:md: 2015
:dk: 2014
:pt: 2014
:hu: 2014
:pl: 2014
:mk: 2014
:ie: 2015
:it: 2014
:is: 2014
:ro: 2014
:nl: 2014
:fr: 2014
:no: 2014
:by: 2015
:ge: 2014
:ch: 2014
:lt: 2015
:lv: 2015
:es: 2015
:at: 2014
:gr: 2015
:mt: 2015
:be: 2015
2014 > 17 | 2015 > 12
 
Sim
belgium

Sim

Well-known member
Joined
October 1, 2009
Posts
19,917
Location
Evergem, Belgium
:ee: 2015
:se: 2014
:ge: 2015
:sl: 2015
:fi: 2014
:uk: 2015
:md: 2014
:dk: 2014
:pt: 2014
:hu: 2014
:pl: 2014
:mk: 2014
:ie: 2014
:it: 2015
:is: 2014
:ro: 2014
:nl: 2014
:fr: 2015
:no: 2014
:by: 2015
:ge: 2015
:ch: 2014
:lt: 2015
:lv: 2015
:es: 2014
:at: 2014
:gr: 2015
:mt: 2015
:be: 2015
 
Gera11

Gera11

WorldVision Mod
Staff member
Joined
October 16, 2011
Posts
23,148
Location
București
:am: - 2014
:at: - 2014
:by: - 2015
:be: - 2015
:dk: - 2015
:ee: - 2015
:fi: - 2015
:fr: - 2015
:mk: - 2014
:ge: - 2015
:de: - 2015
:gr: - 2014
:hu: - 2014
:il: - 2015
:ie: - 2014
:is: - 2015
:it: - 2015
:lv: - 2015
:lt: - 2015
:mt: - 2015
:md: - 2014
:nl: - 2015
:no: - 2015
:pl: - 2014
:pt: - 2014
:ro: - 2014
:sl: - 2015
:es: - 2015
:se: - 2015
:ch: - 2014
United%20Kingdom%28Great%20Britain%29.png
- 2014

2014: 12
2015: 18

2015 isn't that bad after all :lol:
 
united_states

stageman96

Member
Joined
March 17, 2015
Posts
7
:al: 2014
:am: 2014
:at: 2014
:az: 2015
:by: 2015
:be: 2015
:dk: 2015
:ee: 2015
:fi: 2014
:fr: 2014
:ge: 2014
:de: 2015
:gr: 2014
:hu: 2014
:is: 2014
:ie: 2015
:il: 2015
:it: 2015
:lv: 2015
:lt: 2015
:mk: 2014
:mt: 2015
:md: 2015
:nl: 2014
:no: 2014
:pl: 2014
:pt: 2014
:ro: 2014
:ru: 2015
:sm: 2014
:sl: 2015
:es: 2014
:se: 2015
:ch: 2014
:uk: 2014

2014: 19
2015: 16
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom